The Other Montreal Canadiens Trade from this Summer

In Featured, Rob Elbaz by Rob Elbaz2 Comments

There’s been plenty of talk about the PK Subban – Shea Weber trade, and for good reason, but there was another trade that had a big impact on the Canadiens’ roster, the one that sent Lars Eller to Washington in return for a pair second round picks in the 2017 and 2018 draft. The trade also made room to acquire and sign Andrew Shaw to a six-year 23 million dollar contract, and freed up a spot at center on the Canadiens’ third line.

Lars Eller is really everything you could want in a third line center. He’s got size, he skates well with the puck, and he might be as good defensively as any bottom six forward in the league. In theory, he’s perfectly suited to fit in to what’s supposed to be a tougher, grittier Habs team on a shutdown line that’s also expected to chip in offensively. But by trading him, the Canadiens made the de facto decision to slot David Desharnais into that position, and for the exact same 3.5 million dollar cap hit.

It goes without saying that Desharnais doesn’t have Eller’s size, and to make matters worse, his offensive effectiveness has also taken a sharp downturn in recent seasons. The fact that Desharnais’s contract ends after this season while Eller’s lasts until 2018 could help to explain the trade, but there is another scenario that could bode worse for Habs fans.

We can’t change the past, but it’s worth asking if Marc Bergevin would have rather kept Lars Eller instead, if only he could find a taker for Desharnais; or was it simply the plan to trade Eller all along? If Bergevin did shop Desharnais around but had to settle for a pair of second round draft picks to ship out of Eller instead, what does that say about the shape of the roster this season?

Theoretically, a third line of Lars Eller, Andrew Shaw, and any number of wingers from Daniel Carr to Phillip Danault to Artturi Lehkonen could stifle top lines of opposing teams while chipping in offensively from time to time. With Desharnais filling that slot instead, the pressure to contribute offensively goes up, since in theory, his line wouldn’t be as capable at tackling the toughest defensive assignments.

Eller was leaned on heavily to kill penalties, something Desharnais is rarely asked to do. And while Eller had half as much power play time as Desharnais last season, he managed 11 power play shots to Desharnais’s 12.

Desharnais racked up points at a rate of 1.75 for every 60 minutes of ice time last season, while Eller averaged just 1.30, but Desharnais’s numbers are down from 2.04 points/60 the season before, and 2.30 in 2014. Eller has maintained a fairly consistent productivity range over that span, but he’s also never shown flashes again of the 2.64 points/60 he achieved in the lockout shortened 2013 season. Still, given the direction each player is trending, it will be a challenge for Desharnais to outproduce Eller this season.

The 2016-2017 campaign has just started, but it already seems evident that, given his versatility, Eller would have been an upgrade over Desharnais in the third line center slot.

In the end, Habs fans are left to wonder whether Bergevin decided keeping Desharnais was the better option, or whether none of the 29 other NHL teams would even take Desharnais if Bergevin threw in extra perks like draft picks or prospects.

There are a couple other factors at play here that are also worth mentioning. The development of Michael McCarron, who is shaping up to be a big part of the Habs future, as well as the acquisition of Danault, who could also be called upon this season to fill the role if and when injuries strike. If another player steps up, it’s possible to see Desharnais on the trading block at the deadline regardless of where the Habs are positioned. And if Desharnais fends off all other challengers, the internal competition could still help get the most out of the veteran center.


  1. I was so sad when I learned about the Eller trade! Even there was no taker, MB should have made plans to bury Deharnais in the minor. Personally, I think the impact of trading Eller might be greater than trading Subban. With Subban’s trade, they at least received a good albeit aging Weber (Note: Weber did not impress in his 2 games). With Eller gone, they settled with a Deharnais-Shaw-Carr trio which is nothing more than a mediocre 3rd line, not great offensively and even worse defensively. Sad!

  2. Glad eller is gone. So sick of the dd haters who loved puppy dog zero offense larry. DD outproduced larry even when moen and darche were his wingers in first yr and a half. Put dd with 2 serious offensive guys with size and it works. I’d actually go;

    Pacc dd radz
    Lekhonen Galch gallagher
    Carr Pleks shaw
    Flynn Danault byron

Leave a Comment